Menu

Traditional Cookies

Everything at Sugar Magic Bakery, LLC is prepared with high quality ingredients and baked to order. The standard size of our cookies is 4 oz. before they are baked. Special arrangements may be made for smaller sizes. There is a 6-cookie same-flavor minimum per order – 50% non-refundable deposit is due 5 days prior to pick up date. Balance is due upon delivery.

Cookie Prices

*All cookies are 4 oz. to 6 oz.

1/2 Dozen = $30
1 Dozen = $50

Smores Cookies
Chunks of Hershey Bars, Graham Crackers and Stuffed with Homemade Marshmallows

Carrot Cake Cookies
Freshly Grated Carrots Make for a Moist and Delicious Cookie Topped with Heavenly Cream Cheese Frosting.

Cinnamon Roll Cookies
Just Like Classic Cinnamon Rolls. A Cookie Topped with Cream Cheese Buttercream Frosting.

Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
Chewy and Loaded with Raisins and Cinnamon for that Classic Taste.

Chocolate Mint Cookies
Why Not Turn an After Dinner Mint into a Desert? So Good!

Birthday Cake Cookies – My Kid’s Favorite!
This Cookie is Covered in Sprinkles and Tastes Just like a Birthday Cake. What’s Not to Love?

Chocolate Chip Cookies
Better than Grandma Used to Make with Brown Butter, Semi-sweet Chocolate Chips and Milk Chocolate Chips.

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies
Chewy, Sweet and Chocolatey – No Real Description Needed!

Butterscotch, Toffee & Pecan Cookies – WOW!
This Cookie is So Tasty! You Will Not be Disappointed!

Boozy Cookies

Mudslide Cookie
Made with Kahlua and topped with a Bailey’s Irish Cream glaze. A boozy cookie for coffee lovers!

Drunken Fireball Snickerdoodle
This cookie tastes like your classic snickerdoodle but with an extra kick of cinnamon whiskey!

Lime Margarita Cookies
These are Amazing! They Taste Just Like a Margarita, Right Down to the 1800 Blanco Tequila, Triple Sec and Fresh Lime Juice.

Boozy Banana Cream Pie Cookies
I took the Incredible Non-boozy Banana Cream Pie Cookies and Added Some Really Good Banana Sippin’ Liquor to Them – Now They are Just as Good With a Little Kick!

Deep Dish Bourbon Chocolate Chip Toasted
Pecan Cookies
Start with a great cookie recipe and add a little Elija Craig Bourbon (Again, Best Ingredients). These are Just Incredible!

Coconut Almond Cookies Topped with an
Amaretto Disaranno Butter Cream Frosting.
You Cannot Get Enough of this Combination!

Boozy Dark Chocolate Cookies
I use Guinness Extra Stout which enhances the dark cocoa, and chunks of semi sweet Chocolate. Such a rich and delicious Cookie.

More Goodies

Sourdough Brownies
Plain or with Pecans
$25 pan (9” x 9”)

Sourdough S’mores Brownies
Graham Cracker Crust, Topped with Homemade Marshmallow
$30 pan (9” x 9”)

Rice Krispie Treats
Plain – Chocolate – Fruity
$20 pan (9” x 13”)

Texas Rice Krispie Treats
Rice Krispie with a Little Crushed Prezel Added, Followed by a Layer of Caramel and Topped with a Layer of Chocolate
$25 pan (9” x 13”)

Fudge
$25 pan (8” x 8”)
Chocolate
Cookies-n-Cream
Turtle (Chocolate, Caramel, Pecan)
Unicorn
Birthday Cake

Protein Bars
$25 pan (8” x 8”)
Chocolate
Strawberry Vanilla Cream
Raisin Vanilla
Bananna